In the three months ending June 2026, the median home sale in Dublin was $1.3 million, up 0.7 percent from the same stretch a year earlier. Over that same window, the median price per square foot in Dublin fell 15.3 percent. Those two numbers describe the same market, the same three months, the same set of closed sales. One says values are holding. The other says they're not. Both are true, and the gap between them is the thing worth understanding before you compare a Dublin listing to a Pleasanton one.
Pleasanton runs the same contradiction in reverse. Over the three months ending August 2026, Pleasanton's median sale price fell 8.1 percent year over year to roughly $1.5 million. Its price per square foot, over that same window, rose 2.6 percent. If you only read the median, Pleasanton looks like the city cooling off and Dublin looks like the city holding steady. Read the per-square-foot number instead, and the story flips.
What a Median Price Actually Measures
A median sale price isn't a valuation of the existing housing stock. It's a snapshot of whatever happened to change hands that quarter. If the mix of homes selling shifts toward bigger houses, the median goes up even if no individual home gained a dollar of value. If the mix shifts toward smaller houses, the median goes down even if every seller got a fair price for square footage.
Price per square foot strips out size and asks a narrower question: how much is a buyer paying for the same unit of house. It's not perfect either, since it still mixes lot size, finish level, and location within a city. But when a city's median price and its median price per square foot move in opposite directions, that's usually your signal that the composition of what's selling changed, not that the underlying value of homes changed.
Dublin's newest supply skews large. Master-planned tracts like Dublin Ranch and Dublin Crossing, marketed under the Boulevard name, have been delivering two-story homes on the city's eastern edge for years, and East Dublin's newer stock trades at meaningfully bigger square footage than the smaller ranch homes that make up much of the city's west side. If a larger share of this quarter's closings came from that newer, bigger-footprint inventory, the median price rises simply because a bigger home costs more in total dollars, even while the market is paying less per square foot for it. That's consistent with what the price-per-square-foot decline is showing: buyers pulling back on what they'll pay per unit, while the mix of what's actually selling happens to be larger homes that still carry a higher total price tag.
Pleasanton's inventory skews the other direction. Downtown-adjacent neighborhoods carry an older, smaller-footprint housing stock, while Ruby Hill and other larger-lot communities sit at the high end on total price but not necessarily on a per-square-foot basis once lot premiums are factored in. If more of this quarter's Pleasanton sales came from the smaller, walkable core, the median would fall even as each of those smaller homes commanded a strong price per square foot.
Here's how the three Tri-Valley cities compared over their most recent trailing three-month windows on Redfin's own figures:
| City | Median Sale Price | YoY Change | Price per Sq Ft | YoY Change | Median Days on Market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pleasanton (3 mo. ending Aug 2026) | $1.5M | -8.1% | $805 | +2.6% | 29 days |
| Dublin (3 mo. ending Jun 2026) | $1.3M | +0.7% | $646 | -15.3% | 25 days |
| Livermore (3 mo. ending Jun 2026) | $1.1M | -5.4% | $654 | -1.9% | 13 days |
Livermore Shows What Honest Softening Looks Like
Livermore is the control case here. Its median price fell 5.4 percent and its price per square foot fell 1.9 percent over the same trailing window. Both numbers moved the same direction. That's what a market actually cooling looks like: buyers paying less in total and less per square foot, without a composition shift muddying the read.
Livermore homes still sold fast, a median of 13 days on market, faster than either Dublin or Pleasanton. That's not really a contradiction. Livermore offers the most square footage per dollar in the Tri-Valley, and it's the one city in the corridor without BART service, relying instead on the Altamont Corridor Express train and, eventually, the planned Valley Link rail extension from Dublin/Pleasanton BART toward Vasco Road. Buyers who prioritize space and Livermore Valley's wine country setting, home to more than 50 wineries, seem willing to move quickly on a genuinely softening price rather than wait for a better one. Genuine value declines and fast sales aren't opposites. They can both be a sign that price discipline is working.
Why This Matters If You're Comparing Dublin and Pleasanton
If you're weighing a move between Dublin and Pleasanton, the citywide median is the least useful number on the page. Two homes at the same total price in these two cities can represent very different value depending on square footage, lot size, and vintage, and the composition effect above explains why the headline trend in one city can look like the opposite of what's actually happening to comparable homes.
A few things worth checking before you anchor to either city's median:
- Ask for a comp set matched on square footage and build year, not just city and price range. A same-size, same-vintage comparison will tell you more than either city's median.
- Look at price per square foot on the specific streets or subdivisions you're considering, since East Dublin, Central Dublin, and West Dublin behave differently from each other, and downtown Pleasanton behaves differently from Ruby Hill.
- If you're looking at newer construction in Dublin Crossing or similar tracts, budget for the Community Facilities District special tax that funds the neighborhood's infrastructure. Dublin's CFDs are recorded liens tied to the parcel, and the specifics vary by district and phase, so it's worth confirming the exact charge on any parcel through the city's own Community Facilities Districts page before writing an offer.
- Watch what happens to Pleasanton's mix going forward. The area around Stoneridge Mall has been approved for mixed-use housing, and new supply there could shift the city's median again in a direction that has nothing to do with how much any existing home is worth.
None of this means Dublin is a weak market or Pleasanton is a strong one. It means the number most buyers reach for first, the citywide median, is measuring the wrong thing when you're trying to compare two cities. It measures what sold, not what a specific home is worth. The price per square foot on homes that actually match what you're shopping for gets you closer to an honest answer.
If you're comparing Dublin, Pleasanton, and Livermore for your next move and want the comps pulled on actual matched square footage rather than a citywide average, Felicia Duncan can walk through the specific streets and vintages you're considering before you write an offer.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.